Cookies & Coffee in Staten Island, NY
Problem Baker is a family-owned cookie and coffee shop serving Staten Island, New York. We bake bold, handcrafted cookie flavors and make specialty coffee, matcha, refreshers, and flavored milks to order.
Visit us at 870 Castleton Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310, or place an order for pickup or local delivery.
Handcrafted Cookies and Specialty Coffee
Our cookie lineup is built around big flavor, premium ingredients, and a fresh-baked texture. Choose from house favorites including Chocolate Chip Sea Salt, Oreo Cookies N Cream, Pistachio Knafa, Ube, S'mores, Red Velvet Oreo, and more. Pair your box with one of our signature lattes, matcha drinks, or fruit refreshers.
Explore the Problem Baker menu to see our cookie and drink lineup.
Pickup and Local Delivery in Staten Island
Skip the line and view today's availability through our local ordering portal. Orders can be placed for convenient pickup or delivery near our Staten Island shop.
Order Problem Baker in Staten Island.
Cookie Catering and Large Orders
Planning an office meeting, school celebration, wedding, birthday, or community event? Problem Baker offers fresh cookie drops, signature drinks, gift-ready packaging, and a staffed branded cart for larger events throughout New York and New Jersey.
Explore cookie catering and event service, or email info@problembaker.com.
Shipping Cookies Nationwide
Not nearby? Build a custom box of full-size or mini cookies and have it baked fresh in New York and shipped nationwide.